Donald Trump's Racial Comments Spark Concern Over "Race Realism" Resurgence
US President Donald Trump made comments about people from Somalia having low IQs at a World Economic Forum meeting in Davos, echoing similar sentiments expressed by his son, Donald Trump Jr.

The re-emergence of racial views on human nature that were thought to have been eradicated is a disturbing trend in Western politics. US President Donald Trump's statements about people from Somalia having low IQs at this year's World Economic Forum meeting in Davos are a stark example of these views.
His son, Donald Trump Jr, made similar comments about Haitian people in 2024, and the consequences of such rhetoric have been severe. The Trump administration has since ended the protected status of both Somali and Haitian migrants in the US.
These statements are part of a larger narrative that sees black or brown people as inherently intellectually inferior to white people. This racist ideology is still present in some academic journals today, where it fuels far-right propaganda in major democracies around the world.
Narratives about the supposed intellectual superiority of one racial group over another have become a staple of misinformation strategies on social media and are being used to bolster political movements.
This re-emergence of "race realism" or "race science is not supported by scientific evidence, yet it masquerades as legitimate research. Nathan Cofnas, a member of this community, has been accused of plagiarism, drawing attention to his involvement with the network.
Cofnas's connections to other individuals who make unsubstantiated claims about racial groups are also cause for concern. Some within this network have affiliations with universities, lending an air of legitimacy to their work despite its methodological flaws.
Their research regularly appears in mainstream academic journals, often without adequate scrutiny or engagement with rigorous scientific methodologies, raising questions about how they manage to publish such flawed studies and what the consequences are.
The proponents of hereditarianism claim to be a persecuted group of scientists who are denied the freedom to pursue their research due to ideological bias.
However, this self-portrayal is at odds with the actual state of scientific knowledge on the matter. Despite their claims, hereditarian thinking has been consistently debunked by evidence from various fields of study.
One of the most significant challenges to hereditarianism came in the 1970s when evolutionary biologist Richard Lewontin demonstrated that genetic variation within human populations far exceeds differences between them.
Lewontin's findings have stood the test of time, and subsequent advances in genetics have only reinforced his conclusions. The human genome is a complex tapestry of genetic variation, with no clear-cut clusters corresponding to traditional notions of racial groups.
Skin color and other physical traits do exhibit geographical variations, but these are primarily adaptations to local environmental conditions rather than racial characteristics.
Some genetic variants associated with lighter skin tones, for instance, have their origins in Africa, while the ability to digest lactose is found in populations across Europe, Asia, and Africa.
The accumulation of new knowledge about the human genome has only served to underscore Lewontin's original findings. Knowing someone's race does not provide any meaningful insight into their genetic makeup or potential abilities.
Genetic variation within human groups is a far more significant factor than differences between them, rendering hereditarian claims based on racial categories increasingly untenable.
Recent discoveries in the field of ancient DNA have significantly impacted our understanding of genetic differences between human populations. The study of DNA from archaeological sites has revealed a complex history of migration and intermixing across the globe, casting doubt on any notion of genetic purity within racial groups.
The complexity of human genetics is often overlooked by proponents of race science in favor of simplistic views of humanity. However, scientists who have employed rigorous methods to study our species have consistently challenged these oversimplifications.
IQ test results are frequently cited as evidence of genetic differences between racial groups, but the data underlying these claims is shaky at best. These studies often rely on flawed assumptions and methodologies that fail to account for the significant role of education in determining IQ scores.
The national IQ database, a key source of information for hereditarians, has been repeatedly shown to be methodologically flawed. The difficulties inherent in measuring intelligence across diverse cultures with varying levels of formal education cannot be overstated.
Critics have pointed out that the database's methods do not meet even basic standards of scientific rigor. Moreover, analysis suggests that low IQ samples were selectively chosen to represent sub-Saharan Africa, artificially lowering the reported IQ for black populations.
The Flynn effect, which documents a significant rise in IQ scores over the 20th and 21st centuries, unequivocally demonstrates the environmental determinants of intelligence. This phenomenon cannot be explained by genetic factors, but rather by changes in our surroundings and experiences.
Intelligence is a multifaceted concept that defies easy definition or measurement. IQ tests are limited to assessing specific cognitive abilities while ignoring other essential aspects of human intelligence, such as social intelligence or creativity.
The social brain hypothesis suggests that humans have evolved remarkable intellectual abilities to manage complex social issues. However, this idea is largely absent from discussions among race scientists. Instead, they focus on other factors that contribute to human intelligence.
These factors include cooperative child rearing and a heavy reliance on culture and learning. Both of these involve our social relationships and have been overlooked by race scientists in their research.
Mainstream opinion in the evolutionary behavioral sciences holds that all human groups are cognitively similar, with individual differences existing within each group. This diversity stems from our species' ability to adapt flexibly to its environment, particularly due to our reliance on culture and social learning.
This flexibility is a key aspect of human behavior, allowing us to thrive in various environments without needing to develop different psychologies for each one. In contrast, race scientists rely on simplistic explanations for the supposed evolution of racial differences in traits such as intelligence.
For instance, they propose that cold winters in Europe and east Asia drove the evolution of greater intelligence after humans migrated out of Africa. However, this theory relies on unproven assumptions about environmental differences between Africa and other parts of the world.
The same challenges faced by early human migrants in Africa would have required similar adaptability and innovation as those encountered elsewhere. Yet race scientists provide no evidence to support their claims, instead relying on unsubstantiated theories.
Their methods also diverge from standard practices in evolutionary biology, which emphasize the importance of archaeological evidence and rigorous testing of hypotheses. By ignoring these principles, race scientists create a flawed narrative that lacks scientific backing.
The lack of attention paid to social intelligence and creativity in IQ tests further highlights the limitations of current measures of human intelligence.
The notion of hereditarianism has been thoroughly debunked across various fields of study, including genetics, anthropology, evolutionary biology, and psychology.
To appreciate the full implications of this concept, it's essential to consider its historical context. In the early 20th century, eugenics was a widely accepted ideology that viewed human populations as being inherently unequal.
The widespread adoption of simplistic and deterministic views on racial differences led to devastating consequences. When certain groups were deemed responsible for their own disadvantages, society was absolved of any responsibility to help them.
This flawed logic was used to justify the implementation of eugenic sterilization laws, which aimed to prevent individuals considered defective from reproducing without their consent. The ultimate goal was to create a supposedly superior population by eliminating what were deemed undesirable traits.
The atrocities committed during World War II served as a stark reminder of the dangers of such ideologies. As the world grappled with the horrors of the Nazi regime, mainstream research began to reject eugenics and race science.
However, even before the war's end, the scientific community was starting to question the validity of eugenic claims. Advances in genetics and biology revealed that human variation is far more complex than previously thought, defying simplistic categorizations based on socially recognized racial or class distinctions.
The Pioneer Fund, a nonprofit foundation established by a US textile magnate in the 1930s, played a significant role in promoting pseudo-scientific research on race science. The fund's goals included supporting research that would justify segregation and fighting against desegregation efforts in the United States.
The Pioneer Fund's legacy lives on through its continued funding of research that perpetuates outdated and debunked ideas about racial differences.
Despite being taken over by a new group of researchers in the 21st century, the fund's remaining assets were redirected into a new company called Polygenic Scores LLC, which is essentially a rebranded version of the Human Diversity Foundation. This shift in ownership has allowed proponents of race science" to continue their research and publication efforts without interruption.
Academic journals that publish peer-reviewed articles are typically strict about the quality and rigor of research they accept, but somehow, papers on race science still manage to slip through the cracks and appear in mainstream social science or humanities journals.
Facts based on reporting originally published by Ars Technica.
You may republish this story, in full or in part, if you credit Noti Group and link to it (licence CC BY 4.0). Photos are not included.











