Friday, October 9, 2026
Noti Group
Entertainment

Jessica Chastain Stars in Supernatural Horror Film Other Mommy

The movie follows a young girl who senses that something is amiss in her household and begins to suspect that her mother may not be what she seems.

‘Other Mommy’ Review: Jessica Chastain Commits Admirably to an Otherwise Flimsy Supernatural Chiller
Source: The Hollywood Reporter

Jessica Chastain takes on another maternal role in the supernatural horror film Other Mommy, her third outing in this particular genre after Mama and Mothers' Instinct. The movie, directed by Rob Savage, is a departure from the more conventional demon-slaying fare of its predecessors.

The story revolves around 7-year-old Bela, a sensitive child who senses that something is amiss in her household. Her mother, Ursula, played by Chastain, is preoccupied with her career and often leaves childcare to her husband, Russell. The tension between the couple is palpable, and it soon becomes clear what's causing their marital strain.

Ursula and Russell's relationship appears strained, with a sense of sadness hanging over him in his wife's presence. Chastain brings depth to this complex character, but even her talents can't elevate the otherwise flimsy plot. The film's attempts at scares are occasionally effective, but they're not enough to sustain the narrative.

The movie explores themes of childhood intuition and the ability of young children to pick up on the emotions of those around them. It's a clever conceit, although one that's not fully developed in this particular story. Bela, played by Arabella Olivia Clark, is a talented newcomer who brings a sense of vulnerability to her character.

Other Mommy is based on Josh Malerman's novel Incidents Around the House, with Nathan Elston adapting it for the screen. The film marks a departure from Malerman's usual genre, but it shares some of the same themes and ideas that have made his work so compelling in the past.

The film's portrayal of Other Mommy as a loving companion to Bela raises questions about the nature of this supernatural entity. While it is depicted as being more attentive and affectionate than Ursula, its true intentions remain unclear.

As the story unfolds, Other Mommy becomes increasingly menacing, creating an atmosphere of unease that is not fully realized due to a lack of build-up. The film's pacing suffers from this oversight, making it difficult for the audience to become invested in the characters' plight.

Other Mommy's powers are shown to be unpredictable and selective, allowing it to transport people and objects only when convenient to the narrative. This inconsistency undermines the entity's credibility and makes its actions feel arbitrary rather than menacing.

The film's use of Other Mommy as a plot device raises questions about the motivations behind its behavior. Is it genuinely trying to help Bela, or is there something more sinister at play?

In an effort to create tension, the film relies on jump scares and half-baked mythology, but these elements fall flat due to their lack of depth and coherence. The result is a vacuous collection of unsettling moments that fail to coalesce into a compelling narrative.

The film's narrative struggles to balance its tone, veering abruptly between ominous and comedic moments that fail to coalesce into a cohesive story.

One of the most puzzling aspects is the sudden urgency Other Mommy displays in convincing Bela to let it into her heart. The motivation behind this sudden push is left unexplained, leaving the audience wondering what triggered this change in pace.

The script attempts to provide some context by hinting that Other Mommy has been building a relationship with Bela over time, but only reveals its true intentions when the cameras are rolling. This feels like a contrived plot device designed to add drama to an otherwise predictable storyline.

As the story meanders on, it touches on a poignant theme: parenthood can be a grueling responsibility that not all parents aspire to. However, this insightful moment is overshadowed by the film's uneven tone and lack of focus.

As the story unfolds, Jessica Chastain brings her A-game to the role of the enigmatic Ursula, infusing it with a menacing presence that's hard to ignore. Her portrayal is marked by flashes of unsettling smiles and erratic behavior, making her character seem both intimidating and unpredictable.

In addition to Chastain's commendable performance, the film's visuals are also noteworthy, thanks in part to director Julius Savage's keen eye for composition. He expertly navigates the fine line between coherence and chaos, often shooting scenes from precise angles that convey complex emotions with ease.

One particularly striking moment occurs when a father-daughter conversation is captured through a gap between building blocks, highlighting their emotional distance and separation. However, this poignant exchange is soon disrupted by an unrelated sequence involving Chuck E.

The film's tone remains inconsistent, veering wildly between moments of genuine tension and others that feel disconnected or even nonsensical. Despite some notable visual flourishes, the narrative struggles to find its footing, leaving viewers with a sense of unease rather than resolution.

The film's trailer for "Other Mommy was a promising and well-crafted preview of what was to come, but unfortunately, the actual movie falls short of its potential. Despite some visually striking moments, the narrative fails to deliver a satisfying experience.

It seems that this is not an isolated incident, as other films have also suffered from a disconnect between their trailers and final products. The trailer for Battle: Los Angeles was particularly notable, setting up an ominous tone that ultimately gave way to a lackluster action movie. Similarly, the teaser for Billy Lynn's Long Halftime Walk hinted at depth and complexity that was not fully realized in the finished film.

The result is a movie that has some captivating visuals but lacks emotional resonance or genuine scares, leaving viewers with an unsatisfying experience. With its failure to deliver on its promise, Other Mommy" ends up being a disappointing follow-up to its intriguing trailer.

Facts based on reporting originally published by The Hollywood Reporter.

You may republish this story, in full or in part, if you credit Noti Group and link to it (licence CC BY 4.0). Photos are not included.